Art 3: The Parquet Under the Bed (Looking After the Box)
Lionel Anidjar, Hotel Project Director - Global Asset Solutions

Value engineering without making the hotel ordinary
Expensive parquet beneath a rug, beneath a bed. Really?
It’s the kind of line item worth questioning in any value engineering exercise. Nobody walks on it, nobody sees it, and it costs a fortune. Yet a showpiece that carries the hotel’s story deserves defending just as firmly. Value engineering isn’t about spending less everywhere. It’s about knowing where the money is working.
The previous article made the case for the spaces guests never see. This is the stage where those spaces, and everything else in the building, are tested against the budget. A useful definition of good value engineering is simple: reduce cost intelligently, without the guest noticing and without making the team’s job harder. That’s simple to say and much harder to do.
The worst outcome of value engineering is not a cheaper hotel. It is a more ordinary one.
Pay for what is seen and touched
The parquet is not an isolated case. The same question applies across the building: where does the guest actually see or touch this?
Take marble. Guests see its surface, never its thickness. A thinner slab, or stone on a honeycomb backing, looks identical once installed, weighs less and costs less to install, though it may not be cheaper in the end.
Take joinery. If solid wood is going to be painted, the species makes no difference. Paying for a premium timber that will disappear under lacquer is money spent on nobody.
Take ceilings. A mosaic more than four metres above the floor is beautiful on a drawing. From the floor, nobody will ever guess its texture, and a simpler finish gives the same effect.
The flat cut
The instruction I find least useful is “take ten per cent out of every package”. It assumes every consultant has padded their scope equally. They haven’t. Some packages have real room to move. Others are already at the sensible minimum, and a forced cut there removes something the hotel needs.
So the starting point is questions, not percentages. Where will this material be seen? What does the guest actually experience? Could something else deliver the same look and performance? With the parquet, the answer depends on how the room is laid out and where the rug sits. Perhaps the timber only needs to run where it’s visible. The point is to ask, rather than assume the most expensive finish belongs everywhere.
Worth defending
The reverse applies too. If a piece is central to the narrative, the thing guests photograph and remember, cutting it can weaken the whole space. It is often better to keep it and find the money elsewhere.
Designers deserve real respect in this process, and they won’t always welcome proposed cuts. Sometimes their objection is right, because the change would break the coherence of the design. That deserves to be heard. The budget doesn’t move, but a considered alternative protects their work far better than a list of isolated cuts.
Constraints are often where originality starts. A tighter budget can push a design towards a local material, a regional craftsperson or a reclaimed piece that no competitor has, instead of the finish every hotel chose this year.
Never on the list
Some items should never be value engineered, and soundproofing comes first. A guest will forgive a simpler finish. They will not forgive a sleepless night. Acoustic separation between rooms, from corridors and from plant is what guests remember; once the walls are built, it cannot be fixed without taking rooms out of service. It stays off the list.
The necessary evil
Spas and gyms are a necessary evil. Without them, a hotel cannot claim to be luxury. With them come real costs: space, staff, energy and maintenance. They rarely pay their way. A large gym does not earn more than a small one, because hotel guests use it free of charge, and outside memberships have never proven to generate significant revenue in hotels.
The better question is what the space could earn. Recovery and longevity treatments, such as cryotherapy, infrared saunas, cold plunges, compression therapy or red-light sessions, can be charged separately, unlike the pool or the gym. Giving floor area to treatments guests will pay for, rather than to a larger free facility, is value engineering at its most useful: not spending less, but making the space work. Treatments go in and out of fashion, so the fit-out should stay flexible enough to change them as demand shifts.
Time or money, not both
At some point, either time or money has to lead. The word “or” matters. A saving that puts the opening date at risk is a completely different decision from one that leaves the programme untouched. With construction and financing costs where they are today, a late opening can easily wipe out the saving it was meant to deliver.
Costs aren’t standing still either. Construction prices are rising by around 4% to 5% a year worldwide, according to Turner & Townsend. Labour shortages are the main cause, and they are among the most acute in Europe and Asia, while energy prices linked to the conflict in the Middle East are pushing up some materials. So every month of delay costs more than the one before.
European prices underline the stakes. According to GAS’s European Hotel Transactions Report 2025, luxury hotels traded at around €661,000 per key last year, and upscale hotels at around €307,000. Every decision taken in value engineering is measured against the value of that asset.
Time also means the life of what we buy. Something can look perfectly fine at opening and become a problem in year three.
The savings that cost more
The real danger is false economy: a saving on the project budget that quietly becomes a cost on the operating budget.
It happens on most projects. Guestroom floors end up with no pantry, barely a closet, and the answer is always the same: operations will work it out. They rarely can. Every missing pantry becomes extra trips, longer rotations and trolleys waiting in corridors every day for the life of the hotel. The second article put a number on one version of this; value engineering is usually where it starts.
Consider an illustrative case, not taken from a real project. Say a layout change saves €60,000 in construction, perhaps by removing a floor pantry or simplifying a service route. But it adds walking and handling equivalent to half a full-time post. At a fully loaded cost of €45,000 a year, that’s €22,500 every year. Over a fifteen-year management agreement, it comes to roughly €340,000 before inflation. The project looks €60,000 better. The asset is worse.
The owner needs to see both numbers side by side. Otherwise, we approve one budget while inflating another.
Cheap to buy, expensive to own
The same logic runs through every specification. Judge a substitution by what it costs to clean, maintain, repair and eventually replace it, and by how much energy it uses. A cheaper fitting that must be replaced after five years instead of eight costs more overall. That replacement also happens while the hotel is trading, with rooms out of order.
This matters more now than it used to. Under the recast Energy Performance of Buildings Directive, every new building in the EU must be zero-emission from January 2030, and whole-life carbon, including the carbon embodied in materials, must be calculated and declared, with requirements phasing in from 2028. Lenders, buyers and operators are already asking the same questions, and the market is pricing the answers. In GAS’s European Hotel Transactions Report 2025, ESG-certified assets commanded premiums of up to 5%. A specification chosen today to save a few euros will be judged against those rules at the next valuation, refinancing or sale. Value engineering that ignores this is only reading half the ledger.
Technology on trial
Systems deserve the same scrutiny as finishes. Does this make the task genuinely easier, or does it create something the team has to manage? An extra report is worthless if nobody needs it to make a decision.
Local conditions matter. Where labour is relatively inexpensive, heavy automation is hard to justify. Where it is scarce and costly, removing repetitive work can pay back quickly.
A generation of hoteliers has gone from pencil to calculator, to computers, to the internet, and now to AI. Each step changed how the work was prepared, never why it mattered. AI changes the conversation again. HOTREC’s roadmap sees digital tools and AI taking on recurring work such as reservations, timesheets and inventory control, freeing staff for guests. It may reduce staffing needs in some areas too. The next openings will show how far that goes, and the results will be worth sharing.
For core systems, established products that have been tested and upgraded over time are usually the safer choice. A small portfolio doesn’t have the resources of a large group to build and support bespoke technology. Dependence on one very specific product or supplier should be challenged before selection. It’s easy to get into and very expensive to get out of.
On a recent large project, the access control system was selected because the operator could obtain a group discount. On paper, it was a saving. In practice, it never integrated properly with the hotel’s other systems; it was too complex for the team to run; local support and spare parts were hard to find; and it kept failing after opening. Putting it right cost more than the discount ever saved. A price negotiated for the operator’s portfolio is not the same as value for this owner’s building.
The missing voice in the room
Value engineering usually happens before the operating team is on board. The people who will live with the decisions aren’t there to explain the consequences. That is the gap an owner’s adviser with operational experience can fill.
Experience doesn’t remove the need for questions. It tells you which ones matter. It shows when a supplier’s claim needs testing, when an operator’s requirement needs explaining, and when a challenge to established practice is worthwhile rather than simply making work harder.
The aim is a set of decisions the owner genuinely understands: where money was saved, what was protected, and which compromises were accepted with eyes open. Then step back and look at the complete hotel. Savings that each make sense on their own can add up to a room that doesn’t work. Catching that is exactly what the mock-up room is for, and it is the subject of the next article.
Questions for your next owners’ meeting
Has any package been cut by a flat percentage, and if so, what did the cut remove?
For each major saving, has anyone estimated its effect on operating costs over the contract term?
Are substitutions compared on lifecycle cost, energy use and ESG performance, or on purchase price alone?
Which technology choices create dependence on a single supplier, or were selected for the operator’s group pricing rather than for this building?
Who is speaking for the operating team that hasn’t been hired yet?
Are expensive materials specified where nobody will see them, such as full-thickness stone, premium timber under paint or detailed finishes out of sight?
Has anything affecting acoustic separation been proposed for value engineering, and has it been refused?
Do the spa and gym earn anything, and could part of the space host treatments guests will pay for?
Has every guestroom floor kept its pantry, or is the plan relying on operations to work it out?
Which savings affect the opening date, and which leave the programme untouched?
Which design pieces carry the narrative, and have they been protected?
Where could a tighter budget lead to a more original solution rather than a cheaper copy?



